Viewing Single Post From: Lack of Critique

Viewing Single Post From: Lack of Critique
Allyson	Apr 29 2009, 09:43 PM
Observer of all Posts: 2,337 Group: Root Administrator Member #1 Joined: Jan 29, 2008	I don't mean to be rude Likur, but first of all, I think people are trying their best to give a good critique. Maybe they're being honest and saying what they really think about the story. Take Twilight for example...lots of people love it, and lots of people hate it. They're giving their own opinions on the book...that's what people do when they read a story here. Sometimes they really like it, and they just want to comment on why they like it (or the other way around), and they might not know exactly what they liked and didn't like about it, like others. We can't exactly FORCE people to be good critics, and I don't want to say, "If you only want to say a few things about this story, don't even talk," Some people just aren't good at that. I think all writers need to be prepared that they're story might not have a top-notch critique...if they don't like the one they're given they can either ask for another one from someone else or find a different writing board. I'm sorry you feel this way about the critics. :( You can give classes on critiquing if you want, since you feel so strongly about this and you have a reputation of giving good critiques...maybe it will help some people out. Edited by Allyson, Apr 29 2009, 09:47 PM.
	Check out my deviantART page!

Lack of Critique · Contribute Your Thoughts