Naruto Saigen RP. We hope you enjoy your visit.

You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. If you like what you see why not become part of the community? Click the link below to join.

Register or Login

Otherwise, have a look around or drop by the chat-box in the lower-hand corner.

(Hide)
Welcome! If you can read this then that means you haven’t joined our forum yet, but don’t be worried, all you have to do is register to be a part of all this text based RP goodness!

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Why are the weapons village locked?
Topic Started: Feb 21 2017, 07:28 AM (536 Views)
THP
Member Avatar

I'd understand if it were done like the genma where they're insanely powerful and have repurcussions for the entire village just by existing and because all villages were allocated 2.

Village locking weapons doesn't help balance or OOC logic, it jus leaves a very real possibility of unbalance i power that'll be stuck that way. Why not just lotto each time?
Posted Image

Ouji Hito
Kazekage
Sunagakure no Sato
Wakatsuki, Zai
A-ranked Missing Ninja
Kumogakure no Sato


I honestly didn't realize "akatsuki" was in Zai's name, and i'm pretty embarrassed about it. Think of a better one and pm me it plox.

Most intense. Mission. EVER.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Kitsui
Member Avatar
"They call me Baridi."
Or, why not have it so they are like Genma, you can steal them and whatnot if you perform an S-Rank Plotboard or whatever.
Edited by Kitsui, Feb 21 2017, 08:04 AM.
Different Sides Of The War
The Compassion
Posted Image

Karagata, Yuuto
Chuunin: Kiri
[Lightblue]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 0 A: 0 S: 0
[Creed]
[Companion]
The Invisible
Posted Image

Nonki, Hotaru
Chuunin / Spy: Kumo
[#7FA08C][#FF5416]
D: 0 C: 3 B: 2 A: 0 S: 0
S.T.R.A.T.O.S
King Yautja
The Prodigy/Curse
Posted Image

Shoshiki, Amaya
Jounin: Iwa
[palegoldenrod]
D: 5 C: 5 B: 4 A: 0 S: 0
H.N.K
Wana, Ran, Iji
The Mercenary
Posted Image

Nara, Chikara
A-Rank MN: Konoha
[Purple]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 0 A: 0 S: 0
Setsuzoku
Chie, Yasu, Wakana
Ayuma
The Jashinist
Posted Image

Kijo,Nehan
S-Rank MN: Konoha
[Maroon]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 6 A: 1 S: 0
Chishiki
Graw
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Jinan B
Member Avatar

Because MN can't have nice things
Characters
NameRankVillageOrgColour
Karagata, KirinoGeninKirigakureN/ADarkorange
Komatsu, KazuhikoGeninKonohagakureN/A#5EDDC1

Test Thread
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Kitsui
Member Avatar
"They call me Baridi."
Which is becoming tedious, this site is obviously village orientated.
Different Sides Of The War
The Compassion
Posted Image

Karagata, Yuuto
Chuunin: Kiri
[Lightblue]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 0 A: 0 S: 0
[Creed]
[Companion]
The Invisible
Posted Image

Nonki, Hotaru
Chuunin / Spy: Kumo
[#7FA08C][#FF5416]
D: 0 C: 3 B: 2 A: 0 S: 0
S.T.R.A.T.O.S
King Yautja
The Prodigy/Curse
Posted Image

Shoshiki, Amaya
Jounin: Iwa
[palegoldenrod]
D: 5 C: 5 B: 4 A: 0 S: 0
H.N.K
Wana, Ran, Iji
The Mercenary
Posted Image

Nara, Chikara
A-Rank MN: Konoha
[Purple]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 0 A: 0 S: 0
Setsuzoku
Chie, Yasu, Wakana
Ayuma
The Jashinist
Posted Image

Kijo,Nehan
S-Rank MN: Konoha
[Maroon]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 6 A: 1 S: 0
Chishiki
Graw
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
THP
Member Avatar

that wouldn't fix the balance issue, but should be the case anyways.

We can just make it that on stealing, the thief needs to pay the price of the weapon to the person they're stealing it from
Posted Image

Ouji Hito
Kazekage
Sunagakure no Sato
Wakatsuki, Zai
A-ranked Missing Ninja
Kumogakure no Sato


I honestly didn't realize "akatsuki" was in Zai's name, and i'm pretty embarrassed about it. Think of a better one and pm me it plox.

Most intense. Mission. EVER.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Sia
Member Avatar
#Muramasupremacy
errr. as i recall, MN can go for them as well, for the record
Posted Image
A Compilation of Things to Keep in Mind on NSRP
Kirigakure no Sato
Kumogakure no Sato
Iwagakure no Sato
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Kabu
Member Avatar
Dream Crusher
Sia
Feb 21 2017, 12:40 PM
errr. as i recall, MN can go for them as well, for the record
And I seem to recall someone saying that they get locked to Other Countries if MN do end up winning and successfully retrieving them.
Characters

Kabu's Test Thread
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WrightJustice
Member Avatar
Big Floppy Ding Dong
Some of the arguments brought up when discussing Check's big plot, at least by Onu anyway, is that if something like Rain's glove got lost or stolen it was supposed to be made that they would teleport somewhere where he would find it again (e.g. in his toilet or closet).
Posted Image
What is this?
Characters
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
THP
Member Avatar

soooo bump.

Original arguments still stand.

Posted Image

Ouji Hito
Kazekage
Sunagakure no Sato
Wakatsuki, Zai
A-ranked Missing Ninja
Kumogakure no Sato


I honestly didn't realize "akatsuki" was in Zai's name, and i'm pretty embarrassed about it. Think of a better one and pm me it plox.

Most intense. Mission. EVER.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Ace Trainer
Member Avatar
Maybe you forgot who I am.
Sorry. I'll explain sometime today
The ZealotThe RevolutionaryThe Disciple

Inactivated Characters


Chatango

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Sia
Member Avatar
#Muramasupremacy
Kitsui
Feb 21 2017, 08:04 AM
Or, why not have it so they are like Genma, you can steal them and whatnot if you perform an S-Rank Plotboard or whatever.
I thought this was the case for the weapons too?
Posted Image
A Compilation of Things to Keep in Mind on NSRP
Kirigakure no Sato
Kumogakure no Sato
Iwagakure no Sato
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Jinan B
Member Avatar

Why is it a very real possibility of imbalance if the weapons are decided between villages and not if 1 village could theoretically end up with all 10 weapons? Just wondering if your reasoning extends beyond "because MN"
Characters
NameRankVillageOrgColour
Karagata, KirinoGeninKirigakureN/ADarkorange
Komatsu, KazuhikoGeninKonohagakureN/A#5EDDC1

Test Thread
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Aes Sedai
Member Avatar
~:: Kiri Co-OOC ::~
Sia
Apr 3 2017, 10:48 PM
Kitsui
Feb 21 2017, 08:04 AM
Or, why not have it so they are like Genma, you can steal them and whatnot if you perform an S-Rank Plotboard or whatever.
I thought this was the case for the weapons too?
No you can't steal the weapons after the plotboard to gain them is done. They 'choose' their bearers in a sense. If you steal them, they reappear in the original bearer's things later, or in their home, etc.
Katya's Lil Shoppe *OPEN*
Posted Image
The Dark Breaks

Katya's Test Thread


Kat's Characters
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Ace Trainer
Member Avatar
Maybe you forgot who I am.
Sorry, I kno I said I'd reply sooner but, like, life and stuff

Only the 5 Evils are village locked, the Armoury resets every it gets a new owner. Its impossible to pass the armoury down because "mythical bs" or whatever.

The reason I did it this way was actually because they're so unlike the genma. The genma are "extremely powerful" and a village being in possession of more than the others would give that village a pretty big advantage, at least at a political level. By delegating 2 to each village, it motivates users to act in a way to try and create the imbalance, and take the genma from another village.

The weapons are intended to be the opposite in effect. Individually the weapons are strongish and unique, but nothing extremely special. But all of them together would be a pretty big deal. By allowing an un-even distribution, it gives one village a little bit of a power up, but not an extreme one, and allows for users to act as movers of plot more easily.

So yeah, that was my logic in that decision. Sorry it took so long to respond.
The ZealotThe RevolutionaryThe Disciple

Inactivated Characters


Chatango

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
THP
Member Avatar

That makes sense and I support that logic, except to me it seems like it's the logic that supports not locking them into villages at all.

Since it's not a big deal if a village gets an uneven number, it'd be far better IMO if the fate of the weapons weren't locked to any one village they were immediately lotto'd to. We could just lotto them to a new village each time and let them be affected by plot (be stolen and such like the genma).

Unless I missed something.

and thanks for the reply. Late's better than never.
Posted Image

Ouji Hito
Kazekage
Sunagakure no Sato
Wakatsuki, Zai
A-ranked Missing Ninja
Kumogakure no Sato


I honestly didn't realize "akatsuki" was in Zai's name, and i'm pretty embarrassed about it. Think of a better one and pm me it plox.

Most intense. Mission. EVER.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Takumi
Member Avatar

I'd like to see a compromise on it that seems like it could encourage the plot moving that onu wants. What if the item stays in the village until taken? Kinda like a wand in Harry Potter, except the weapon chooses the user and then the village. So, if inactivity or whatever, the weapon stats in the village, but it can still be taken, and it switches loyalty until taken again.
Saigen Census

Arashi Takumi
Online Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Ace Trainer
Member Avatar
Maybe you forgot who I am.
I mean, I have no authority on it. I was just explain my logic as to why I chose to do it the way I did.
The ZealotThe RevolutionaryThe Disciple

Inactivated Characters


Chatango

Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
THP
Member Avatar

bump
Posted Image

Ouji Hito
Kazekage
Sunagakure no Sato
Wakatsuki, Zai
A-ranked Missing Ninja
Kumogakure no Sato


I honestly didn't realize "akatsuki" was in Zai's name, and i'm pretty embarrassed about it. Think of a better one and pm me it plox.

Most intense. Mission. EVER.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
THP
Member Avatar

Bringing this back to life now that I have authority to do anything about it ;D

Does anybody not agree with making it so the weapons aren't village locked? Once they're lost, they're just relotto'd in general again.
Posted Image

Ouji Hito
Kazekage
Sunagakure no Sato
Wakatsuki, Zai
A-ranked Missing Ninja
Kumogakure no Sato


I honestly didn't realize "akatsuki" was in Zai's name, and i'm pretty embarrassed about it. Think of a better one and pm me it plox.

Most intense. Mission. EVER.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Gara
Member Avatar
Suna OOC #sandlife
IMO I would say for them to be lotto'ed like genma when the owner goes inactive, but for them to also change hands if their owner is beaten/killed. Like Takumi was saying sort of. The Elder Wand in harry potter changes loyalties every time it's owner is beaten or killed, and only works for its current owner. So if you beat someone to the point where there was no denying that you were the winner, even if you didn't kill them, the weapon would change loyalties for you, and would only work for you.
Storm Slayer - Xiao Li - Sunagakure Jounin
Online Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Strategist
No Avatar
Dasutobanī
This hasn't gone into effect yet. Why?
"The Absent one"
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Zao
Member Avatar
Kiri's Black Reaper
Sounds like a solid idea.
Characters
Online Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Kitsui
Member Avatar
"They call me Baridi."
Yeah, still makes no sense that we can't hunt them, yet we can hunt genmas
Different Sides Of The War
The Compassion
Posted Image

Karagata, Yuuto
Chuunin: Kiri
[Lightblue]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 0 A: 0 S: 0
[Creed]
[Companion]
The Invisible
Posted Image

Nonki, Hotaru
Chuunin / Spy: Kumo
[#7FA08C][#FF5416]
D: 0 C: 3 B: 2 A: 0 S: 0
S.T.R.A.T.O.S
King Yautja
The Prodigy/Curse
Posted Image

Shoshiki, Amaya
Jounin: Iwa
[palegoldenrod]
D: 5 C: 5 B: 4 A: 0 S: 0
H.N.K
Wana, Ran, Iji
The Mercenary
Posted Image

Nara, Chikara
A-Rank MN: Konoha
[Purple]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 0 A: 0 S: 0
Setsuzoku
Chie, Yasu, Wakana
Ayuma
The Jashinist
Posted Image

Kijo,Nehan
S-Rank MN: Konoha
[Maroon]
D: 0 C: 0 B: 6 A: 1 S: 0
Chishiki
Graw
Posted Image
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Kabu
Member Avatar
Dream Crusher
The staff is going to be discussing this, we however currently have much bigger concerns on our plate and this isn't anywhere close to being a priority. On behalf of the staff I just ask that you be patient and wait for us to come to an answer.
Characters

Kabu's Test Thread
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
DealsFor.me - The best sales, coupons, and discounts for you
« Previous Topic · Questions and Ideas · Next Topic »
Add Reply



NSRP Discord


Affiliations   Forum Roleplay Shinigami Generation Shinobi Generations


Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.