Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Viewing Single Post From: Monte Belger's interview with the Commission
Stundie Jan 26 2009, 10:19 AM

Woody Box
Jan 26 2009, 06:52 AM
Stundie
Jan 25 2009, 12:22 PM
Woody Box
Jan 24 2009, 05:59 PM
So you think Belger is lying in his statement, Aldo?
How did you come to that conclusion Woody??

Because it's Mineta vs. Belger. If you believe Mineta, Belger must be lying. Mineta claims to have been in contact with Belger before the Pentagon crash, and even that Belger tracked the plane that hit the Pentagon later. Belger mentions nothing like that:

Quote:
 
Between 9:20-9:45 there were many confusing reports about various aircraft being unaccounted for. He heard of a crash on the Indiana/Kentucky border that was thought to be AAL 77. By this point he believes he talked with Bob Baker and Russ Chew at AAL. Jane Garvey talked to Don Carty.


An omission that - in case it happened - would qualify for a lie.



It is not Mineta vs Belger.......lol

Because Belger doesn't mention Mineta until 9:45, that doesn't mean that Belger never spoke to him before hand.

You are ignoring the fact if Belger is correct, that he and Garvey call Mineta, that Mineta was in the PEOC when he says he was as he says he gave this order at 9:45.

The so called interview makes no mention of what Belger was doing beforehand, it's not even in his own words or his own account, just a narrative of his interview. No account or mention of what Belger was doing or who he was speaking to between 9:20-9:45, while all this confusion was going.

There is no reason to think Belger and Mineta are lying or mistaken or contradict each other, for the simple reason their interviews/accounts are mutually exclusive.

Both say the order to bring all flights down was at 9:45, therefore I do not see the problem.
Edited by Stundie, Jan 26 2009, 10:22 AM.
Offline Profile Quote Post
Monte Belger's interview with the Commission · Pentagon