Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Viewing Single Post From: Debunking NIST's August 21, 2008 Final Report on W
Miragememories
Member Avatar

Grit1645
 
"Where did I ever say that NIST didn't have the plans? You are the one that distrusts the NIST completely. Clearly they would not have gotten too far without the building plans.

And obviously these report comments are adequate proof for you that there WERE studs and that NIST then denied it. Sorry if it offends you that this is NOT adequate proof for ME."

Grit1645
 
"Where are the PLANS indicating that there were shear studs on this particular girder, and how many?"

Where are the PLANS?

The NIST has them under lock and key.

The NIST said shear studs for the core girders were not shown in all the design drawings.

In 2004, the NIST unequivocally stated that most of the beams and [floor]girders did have sheer studs.

Posted Image

What part of "most of" suggests to you a reasonable doubt that the critical floor girders were exempted?

It's particularly telling when the NIST, with the original WTC7 design design drawings in hand, stated most of the floor girders had shear studs.

From this very detailed and researched 2004 preliminary report containing a working collapse hypothesis which was not effected by the existence of floor girder shear studs, the NIST releases a 2008 final report which completely denies the existence of shear studs on the floor girders, and that denial just happens to fit perfectly with their new collapse hypothesis.

I don't distrust the NIST completely. The majority of the NIST staff, I'm sure are honest, hard working people
whose integrity is not in doubt. Of the hundreds of people associated with the actual investigation into the collapse of WTC7, only a few would be involved in the final document's critical wording.

Those in the NIST administration overseeing this politically sensitive report, would have the final say in how the findings were presented and interpreted.

MM
Offline Profile Quote Post
Debunking NIST's August 21, 2008 Final Report on W · WTC 7