Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to the Shop!

You're currently viewing our site as a guest, so some features you can't use... like the bubble gum machine. If you join our little cult, you'll be able to take advantage of many member-only features such as a 60 day free trial subscription to HighTimes - A chance to be chosen as a candidate to test the latest penis enlargement cream - A possibility to win a free lifetime supply of Kotex® Maxi-Pads to help with that "not so fresh" feeling - Running around with your pants down around your ankles yelling kiss my ass!!! and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.

sO Click herE to join our Cwazy wHackd in the Head coMmunity!

If you're already a member, wtf you doin!? ffs log in already!




Username:   Password:
Locked Topic
PnP Results; results of Pride n Punishment contest
Topic Started: Jul 30 2011, 12:59:03 PM (2,986 Views)
outsid3r4
Member Avatar


Many soldiers died in this battle. However few survived :thumbsup:
Here are my judgments; in order as I received mods (post will be edited/updated when I get next mods)

Alex189 with his 2002 Dodge Viper GTS
TOTAL = 70/100
Spoiler: click to toggle

SCREENSHOTS
Spoiler: click to toggle



SdkDdt with his 2008 Shelby Terlingua
TOTAL = 30/100
Spoiler: click to toggle

SCREENSHOTS
Spoiler: click to toggle



Rapid X with his 2002 Pontiac Firebird Trans Am
TOTAL = 43/100
Spoiler: click to toggle

SCREENSHOTS
Spoiler: click to toggle


Slyde with his Chaparral 2C
TOTAL = 44/100
Spoiler: click to toggle

SCREENSHOTS
Spoiler: click to toggle


====================
SUMMARY:
====================

Imo Alex189 made best PnP mod, which is good balanced between quality, scratch work and overall completion. 2nd is Slyde who made not-finished car but it's 99,9 % scratched - that counts a lot as u can see in final results. 3rd, Rapid X made good job as well, it just needs lots of improvements as mentioned. Last, SdkDdt made least things to his mod, that's why I said it's ~30% done, it just feels like that.
I tried to be precision and neutral as I could, as judge. Don't blame me, don't beat me, don't be mad about that. Thx all of U guys and good luck with other judges! :urhrhr:
Edited by outsid3r4, Aug 1 2011, 02:08:31 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chipicao
Member Avatar
Fish swim, I fly

Just a heads up, my grading is gonna run a little late. I'm in the process of upgrading my CPU+MB+RAM and I'll have to sell some parts today, leaving me with a notebook that can't run IV :(

alex and RX are almost finished, and I was in the middle of testing sdk's ride last night, but so far alex is clearly the leader. But I haven't had time to test Slyde's mod at all!

Preliminary results - note that they are subject to change at any time (or at least until I finish grading all contestants).

Viper by alex - 63 points


Firebird by Rx - 46.5 points


Terlingua by SdkDdt - 20.5 points


Sadly, Slyde's Chaparral crashes my game when I try to spawn it. I haven;t been able to figure out why, but I'm still trying. OpenIV seems to load it fine though...

My grading may not be 100% accurate, but at least the margin of error is small enough that it doesn't affect the leaderboard.
Edited by Chipicao, Aug 9 2011, 11:44:12 AM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Kotton
Member Avatar
★SoCal CrackHead★

here come my grades.. drip drop style - all vehicles have a possible 113 score

Alex189 - '02 Dodge Viper GTS

68/113

Posted Image

Alex - Results




Rapid X - '02 Pontiac Firebird T/A

52/113

Posted Image

Rx - Results




SdkDdt - '08 Shelby Terlingua

1/113

Posted Image

SdkDdt - Results




Slyde - '65 Chaparral 2C

CTD :/






tyt bro.. I've only done Alex's so far - kinda hard to take a full tour when my daughter's here - it took me over an hour just to score the Viper - and I haven't even done the bonuses or summary yet lol

@Outz, in regards to Rx; "bug on the tyre tread - strange lip like it was wrong connected"

I haven't lookd the mod over yet, but we might need to retract that as a conversion bug, as it seems Zm is the cause (like the floorboard/interior shadows and under boot/bonnet shiz) ..I'd have to see it first tho to confirm that is or isn't what's happening
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
outsid3r4
Member Avatar


OK Kott. I was talking about that:
Posted Image
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chipicao
Member Avatar
Fish swim, I fly

I can confirm I have that too on my bug list.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
SdkDdt
Member Avatar
EUROBEAT FOREVER

I actually don't want do anything about my PnP car when I found my Speedster Turbo is much sexier. But i think quiting is shameful so I finished it basically. :dur: :5150:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Nm69
Member Avatar
★Anti-TROLL★

Its alrite SdkDdt
Atleast u didnt complain :P
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
KSofts
Member Avatar
badassmoFo

Wtf with leather? O.O
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
SdkDdt
Member Avatar
EUROBEAT FOREVER

@nm69
LoL :)
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Kotton
Member Avatar
★SoCal CrackHead★

I don't think that's it Outz - again, I'll see for sure when I test

but this is what I was talkn about being Zm error

http://forum.zmodeler2.com/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=5281
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Rapid X
Member Avatar
-Retired-

I'm definitely not pleased with Outsid3r4's judgement and I hope the other judges would do better for me...

OK I agree that my sills don't look that good and my Engine bay is a HUGE mess but how can't I get more points for baggage compartment?!? It's just as it should be... :shyyyt: I just don't get it.. :5150:

...And the dirt mapping is just the best it can ever get..even glass gets dirty as it should.. :blink:

Bullet registry is another thing, I tested it like 10 times changing the IDE line for better wheel after tire burst..but I get 1... :suicide:

Scale...how can the scale not be accurate when the model is from FM3?! I believe FM3 models have 100% accurate scaling but whatever..Slyde's model is scratch made and has correct scaling but an FM3 model doesn't have..Alex's model is also from FM3 (if I'm not mistaken) and he gets 5 for scaling :fp:

BUGS...I agree with all of them but the tire tread..as I changed it like 5 times but it looks 100% accurate no mismatches in Zm but IG it's different so IDK what's wrong with it... It might be what Kot said.

"Radius in vehicles.ide needs to be fixed (increased)" I don't understand this sentence..wheel radius was tested almost 10 times and in my last test it was good enough..

One more thing is that .wtd couldn't be optimized more as I re-sized all my custom textures as small as possible and made no-alpha textures DXT1, only alpha textures were DXT3,DXT5..

Last...did you test the reflective mirrors? If so I could get a bonus point or 2 for them.. :w/e:

No disrespect to you Outs but I just wanted to tell you my thoughts..

EDIT: The license plate is an extra and IMO it's a matter of taste and person...and a matter of changing a texture.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chipicao
Member Avatar
Fish swim, I fly

While I agree with you on some points (like scale and license plate), most of the issues outsider pointed out are real:
Posted Image Posted Image Posted Image

And I must say I found even more bugs that I'll post when my grading is finished
P.S. There are at least 6 bugs in that last picture alone :D

P.P.S. I for one will give every contestant the right of reply, and if I'm wrong I'll adjust my grading.
Edited by Chipicao, Aug 1 2011, 12:35:11 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Rapid X
Member Avatar
-Retired-

Damn..looks like my second car is 10x worse than my first :gasp: I know it has a lot more bugs than what Outsid3r4 found cause I saw them when I sent the file to you guys but didn't test the front wheel when tire burst.. :suicide:

Alright, I'll take back what I said, sorry Outsid3r4.. :sry:
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Chipicao
Member Avatar
Fish swim, I fly

Don't be sad about it bro. This mod has great potential and I have to say it's my personal favourite (bugs or not). So just stiffen up that upper lip and get back on it!
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
outsid3r4
Member Avatar


All discussions and disagrees should be banned lol ;] Rapid, you are taking this to personally :p I took reflecting mirrors into consideration under interior material settings :) And I think I should be most kindness of all judges cause I'm not so experienced as Chip or Kott :haha:

Posted Image

Anyway I got some props for graduate template's update to descrease points taken per bug. If contestant will 'earn' fe. 50p, and I'll found fe. 7 bugs, he will get 15p. So in this contest noone should get so many points to even get over 50p. So (2nd) in this contest should start only BEST modders (how to find them?), cause weakers will have no chance. I know it's just for fun but I feel serious in this.
And pjs should be counted only this made by contestant. Not taken from somewhere and fitted to his mod :egadz:
Edited by outsid3r4, Aug 1 2011, 01:16:55 PM.
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Kotton
Member Avatar
★SoCal CrackHead★

here come my grades.. drip drop style - all vehicles have a possible 113 score

moved to post #3

Offline Profile Goto Top
 
SdkDdt
Member Avatar
EUROBEAT FOREVER

Alex is the winner now for sure :D
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Kotton
Member Avatar
★SoCal CrackHead★

they still need to go up for votes homie, grading is only part of the score

hope nobody minds, I'm gonna delete all the posts between Outz, Chipi's and mines so the first 3 posts are the results.. and if you do have a problem with it, just hit me up n I'll floatcha 35¢ so you can call some1 who gives a fuck lol
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Nm69
Member Avatar
★Anti-TROLL★

Ur breakin my balls here Man
how about $1.00?
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
Kotton
Member Avatar
★SoCal CrackHead★

sorry bro, I can only finance local calls only.. like to your local suicide or emo's are us hotline lol
Offline Profile Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Free Forums. Reliable service with over 8 years of experience.
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Contests 4IV · Next Topic »
Locked Topic

✜ KotsChopShop® A Suspect Everything/Stripprpmp Industries copyright ©2007-2015 ✜

All trademarks and works contained within KotsChopShop are copyrighted properties
of Suspect Everything/Stripprpmp Industries and/or their respective owners.
All works, files, and/or hyperlinks hosted or provided by KotsChopShop are provided free,
and strictly for educational and entertainment purposes only.


.Wiredvage Theme created by Zeus00 and converted by Wolt of the ZetaBoards Theme Zone