Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to Alternia. We hope you enjoy your visit.

You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Poll Only
  • Pages:
  • 1
Approve this fakemon?
Yes 22 (73.3%)
No 8 (26.7%)
Total Votes: 30
XP
BLAH 1 (100%)
BLAH 0 (0%)
Total Votes: 1
--------------------
Topic Started: Mar 22 2009, 09:03 PM (659 Views)
★ Sora ★
Member Avatar
Overlord of Blowing $hit Up
DS YOU SNAKE! T_T
Edited by Sora, May 13 2009, 10:30 PM.
Posted Image
.::Profile | Journey::.
.::Computer Storage Account::.
.::Alternia's Resident Dragon Trainer::.
Click
.::Staff since: June 12 2009::.
.::Captoris Corporation::.
.::Reffs: 323::.
Off
Profile
Top
 
Jsol
Member Avatar
Alternia's resident Canadian Jew
I approve. I think it could be good for plot purposes.
~: Profile :~ Posted Image :~ Journey ~:
~:~ PC ~:~


Current Team


MOD INFO
Pink since: 03/27/11
Refs done since re-modship: 212
Green since: 08/15/11
Move-Tutors done since re-greenship: 58
Journeys Started: 4
Retired since: 09/04/12
Off
Profile
Top
 
Xander
Member Avatar
Overlord of Random
Third time approving -_- Since it is at 14 votes yes on the other poll you made why am I doing this again?
Off
Profile
Top
 
★ Sora ★
Member Avatar
Overlord of Blowing $hit Up
have to make it official.... THAT's 2, ONE MORE!
Posted Image
.::Profile | Journey::.
.::Computer Storage Account::.
.::Alternia's Resident Dragon Trainer::.
Click
.::Staff since: June 12 2009::.
.::Captoris Corporation::.
.::Reffs: 323::.
Off
Profile
Top
 
Kyuubii
Member Avatar
Underappreciated wonderfulness
I approve, it's... Intersting. I like interesting.
Team:
Spoiler: click to toggle


Current Goals:
Spoiler: click to toggle


Ref Statistics:
Spoiler: click to toggle


Journey ~ Profile ~ Shop ~ ToA Round 1 ~ ToA Round 2
Off
Profile
Top
 
Jsol
Member Avatar
Alternia's resident Canadian Jew
Alright. That's three. I'll add a poll.
~: Profile :~ Posted Image :~ Journey ~:
~:~ PC ~:~


Current Team


MOD INFO
Pink since: 03/27/11
Refs done since re-modship: 212
Green since: 08/15/11
Move-Tutors done since re-greenship: 58
Journeys Started: 4
Retired since: 09/04/12
Off
Profile
Top
 
★ Sora ★
Member Avatar
Overlord of Blowing $hit Up
damn, tha was quick ^^;
Posted Image
.::Profile | Journey::.
.::Computer Storage Account::.
.::Alternia's Resident Dragon Trainer::.
Click
.::Staff since: June 12 2009::.
.::Captoris Corporation::.
.::Reffs: 323::.
Off
Profile
Top
 
Jsol
Member Avatar
Alternia's resident Canadian Jew
Yeah and it already has 3 votes. If only Tezeh got votes this quickly :'(
~: Profile :~ Posted Image :~ Journey ~:
~:~ PC ~:~


Current Team


MOD INFO
Pink since: 03/27/11
Refs done since re-modship: 212
Green since: 08/15/11
Move-Tutors done since re-greenship: 58
Journeys Started: 4
Retired since: 09/04/12
Off
Profile
Top
 
Alexis
Member Avatar

I know that you asked for no negative comments, but if something like this goes to a poll, then people are entitled to voice their reasons.

Basically I'm standing behind my previous statement that introducing this Pokémon, even as a fossil evolution, in my mind defeats the purpose of Magikarp as a Pokémon. It was designed as the weakest Pokémon for a reason, that being that despite being very weak, they have a very powerful evolution which one must work for very hard. This fakemon, in my mind, is the lazy man's way to obtain a Gyarados.
Journey - Profile - Storage
Stuff I Need To Sort Out
Off
Profile
Top
 
Racer
Member Avatar
Overlord of Everything - Darkness Incarnate
Posted Image

I'm agreeing 100% with Lexi on this. It defeats the reason to have Magicarp at all. There is absolutely no real reason to have this set on Alternia, at least in my mind. Primal versions in general are bad ideas. If this one gets accepted, it opens the way for more primals. Besides, this was already defeated once, so why won't you just let it stay dead?
Posted Image

Posted ImagePosted Image
PC Space

Party Pokémon

WANTED:
Off
Profile
Top
 
DarkSlayer1331
Member Avatar
I know you're out there somewhere...
I'm also agreeing with Lexi on this. Love the pic Racer. Honestly I don't know if Falcon or Shad will agree to making this an official Fakemon either.
Posted Image
Journey || PC


Spoiler: click to toggle
Off
Profile
Top
 
★ Sora ★
Member Avatar
Overlord of Blowing $hit Up
XD nice pic Racer. Yeah, I was expecting you 3 to say something, anyway. I don't think anyone else would be able to get a primal up this far, and I won't be making any more soon.

Shad told me to keep the info up, and many people decided that they liked it. I'm not even looking to get one anymore, it just went up again by popular vote. And of course, this would be rarer then rare.

And like Jsol & Nolan, I agree that the Gyarados would make one HELL of a plot device, XD
Posted Image
.::Profile | Journey::.
.::Computer Storage Account::.
.::Alternia's Resident Dragon Trainer::.
Click
.::Staff since: June 12 2009::.
.::Captoris Corporation::.
.::Reffs: 323::.
Off
Profile
Top
 
Flygon Breeder
Member Avatar
The Farming Artist
Well, I think it's awesome! It seems like a real improvement on the uselessness that is Magikarp. And this is a pokemon that you don't have to stick at the back of your party with a bloody EXP share tacked onto it. Blech! I love it. ^-^

Although, maybe should've stopped at Splash, Thrash, and tackle for the karp.
Profile ~ PC ~ Journey ~ Ranch ~ Trades ~ Gallery
If you can't keep the facts straight...
Backread a page or two.
If you don't want to backread...
PLEASE DO NOT REF ME!


There's a post dedicated to personalities of both the pokemon in my current party and those in my box on my profile, just under the mod's post of my pokemon, if you need it.

Thank you for your consideration.
{As a note to mods, the images link to respective Serebii.net and Alterniadex pages.
:barboach

"Swisher"
Status: Okay
Level 11 :male
'The Shoulder Baby'

:cestar

"Nocturne"
Status: Okay
Level 9 :male
'The Playful'

:girafarig

"Lanny"
Status: Hospital-bound
{Broken Legs ~ Permanently Disabled}

Level 10 :male
'The Freakishly Tall'

:trapinch

"Seiran"
Status: Hospital-bound
Level 6 :male
'The Timid'

:meowth

"Talon"
Status: Hospital-bound
Level 10 :female
'The Clever'

:electrike

"Bane"
Status: Hospital-bound
Level 7 :male
'The Puppy'
Off
Profile
Top
 
★ Sora ★
Member Avatar
Overlord of Blowing $hit Up
Good point, the karp doesn't have to be too kickass. With the useless stats raised already, the attacks look kinda overboard.

*edired*

Headsmash is a reward for anyone wanting to get it that high ^^; TMs and below still stand, though.
Posted Image
.::Profile | Journey::.
.::Computer Storage Account::.
.::Alternia's Resident Dragon Trainer::.
Click
.::Staff since: June 12 2009::.
.::Captoris Corporation::.
.::Reffs: 323::.
Off
Profile
Top
 
Alexis
Member Avatar

Even with that change, my opinion stands.
Journey - Profile - Storage
Stuff I Need To Sort Out
Off
Profile
Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
Go to Next Page
« Previous Topic · Archives · Next Topic »
Poll Only
  • Pages:
  • 1